COMMENTARY: Why only MVNOs can check the market power of the incumbents (Part One)

By Tim Denton CHRIS MACDONALD, UNTIL RECENTLY a commissioner of the CRTC, and Peter Menzies, former vice-chairman of telecom at the same agency, recently published a paper called Building Internet Access is Job 1. We think it is a useful contribution to public discussion of matters of national importance. There is much that the Internet Society likes. Before we get on to the subject of mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) – where we differ – we want to set forth our agreements of several large issues. Its central thesis is regulation involves bargains where various conflicting objectives must be balanced....