
By Ahmad Hathout
The largest internet service providers (ISPs) want the CRTC to revisit a decision that mandates the delivery of “typical” internet speeds at all times outside peak periods.
In September, the CRTC ordered all ISPs to establish, by March 10, the “typical” download and upload speeds their customers should expect to receive and commit to deliver them outside of peak hours – 7 pm to 11 pm local time – at all times. Inside of peak congestion hours, they must deliver those typical speeds at least 95 per cent of the time. The new rule, which applies to those subject to the Internet Code, does away with language like “up to” and “maximum” that didn’t provide clarity on expected speed.
But “typical” speeds to be delivered at all times become minimum speeds that cannot be typical, according to a review-and-vary application filed by the Canadian Telecommunications Association (CTA) – on behalf of Rogers, Bell, Quebecor, Cogeco, Eastlink, SaskTel, and Xplore – and co-signed by Telus. The applicants argue that, at the network level, “typical” performance is “inherently somewhere between the highs and lows of performance across users,” meaning some customers will get speeds below typical.
“A speed that must be delivered ‘at all times’ does not describe ordinary or typical performance; it describes a guaranteed floor of the kind associated with dedicated, enterprise-grade services, and under such a standard, any momentary fluctuation, however brief or immaterial and whatever its cause, would constitute a breach,” the applicants argue in the application made public Wednesday, adding those enterprise-grade services come at a price premium compared to mass-market retail services.
“Accordingly, no carrier can guarantee that every customer will receive a particular speed at all times, unless that speed is so low as to cease to be meaningful information to a customer about ordinary performance of a service,” the applicants argue. “Requiring carriers to disclose such a figure but label it as ‘typical’ therefore imposes an obligation that ISPs cannot practically meet or would significantly understate typical service performance and does not meaningfully inform consumers of the typical speed they can expect to receive.”
The applicants are asking the CRTC to modify the decision to allow them to commit to the typical speeds most of the time during peak periods, with customer recourse available when the speeds fall more than 15 per cent below the disclosed speed. Where the CRTC seeks a common metric, they suggest a median, or the speed that 90 per cent of customers achieve or better, in a representative sample of customers during peak hours.
“The Applicants propose that, instead of holding all ISPs to confusing minimum peak and non-peak speed standards labelled as ‘typical’ (with mandatory consumer disclosure of the non-peak minimum), ISPs be required to disclose a coherent and consistently measurable metric that reflects ordinary performance an individual consumer can expect at peak, such that consumers, ISPs, and the CCTS all assess performance against the same reference point – and as Parliament intended.”
As the CRTC chews on that, the applicants are asking for a stay of the entire decision in the meantime. Short of that, they are asking for alternatives in the following order of preference: require that the ISPs disclose and commit to typical speeds by the deadline of March 10, 2027, but allowing them to use methodology that measures ordinary performance, such as a median or average (the CRTC said it was opposed to “mean” or “average” because they are unclear to consumers); or, force ISPs by the same date to disclose typical speeds based on the median speed of a representative sample of the customers of the service during peak hours. If, for the latter, the CRTC doesn’t consider the median metric sufficient, then allow for the speed that 90 per cent of customers achieve or better in a representative sample of customers during peak hours.
Parties have until December 3 to file comments on the interim stay request and until January 11 for the rest of the application.
The applicants raise other issues in their application. They charge that the CRTC hasn’t fully hashed-out how the ISPs – as the carriers of the burden of proof – will be able to show that they are delivering the typical speeds. They argue that the CRTC hasn’t explained how the complaints watchdog – the Commission for Complaints for Telecom-television services (CCTS) – will be able to reconcile different speed tests from consumers and ISPs.
“A speed measurement undertaken via a customer’s device test, for example, may reflect in-home limitations outside of the control of the ISP rather than truly deficient network delivery,” they argue. “While the Decision allows ISPs to use sample-based tests to prove that it was delivering its committed speeds, the Decision has left it to the CCTS to determine, without adequate direction, exactly how to rule when a sample-based test result does not match a consumer device test’s result.
“As a result, the Decision leaves the CCTS on its own to decide, case by case, what evidentiary standard suffices, including what type of testing is adequate to establish a valid complaint, what magnitude and frequency of shortfall breaches the ISP’s speed commitment, and what compensation follows – all of which are substantive policy determinations that subsection 24.2(3)(g) of the [Telecommunications Act] directs the Commission to make,” they add.
They also state that the CRTC has not established how the framework could be applied to wholesale-based retail internet services.
The applicants also say getting the systems up by March 10, 2027 is unrealistic for large players, let alone smaller ones, considering, among other things, the “massive and complex systems undertaking that requires retrieval, association, and presentation of contract and CIS records across an expanse of billing and customer management platforms, for both existing and new customers, in every sales channel.”
The CRTC’s September decision followed a consultation that was prompted by an amendment to the Telecommunications Act by a private member’s bill, which received royal assent in the summer of 2024, that proposed to amend the law to require ISPs to provide Canadians with the “typical” download and upload speeds that customers should expect during peak periods. Large ISPs warned about prescriptive rules on such disclosure.


